Custom Cake Flavors & Pricing in Northern Colorado

Custom Cakes in Northern Colorado | Cactus Cake with Butterfly

Creating the perfect centerpiece for your celebration starts with choosing flavors that taste as amazing as they look. Whether you are planning a wedding in Longmont, a birthday in Firestone, or a special event nearby, Sugar High Cakes offers the finest custom cakes in Northern Colorado.

Most Popular Custom Cake Flavors

Choose from these customer favorites. Don’t see what you’re looking for? Contact me to request a custom flavor!

  • Chocolate Midnight: Rich, dark, and decadent.

  • Classic Vanilla: A timeless favorite, moist and flavorful.

  • Red Velvet: Classic Southern red velvet with a hint of cocoa.

  • Cookies & Cream: Vanilla cake packed with crushed chocolate cookies.

  • Confetti: Our festive vanilla cake with colorful sprinkles baked in.

  • White Chocolate: A sweet and creamy white chocolate cake.

  • Lemon: Bright, zesty, and perfectly tart.

  • Carrot: Made with fresh carrots and a blend of warm spices.

Delicious Filling Options

Add an extra layer of flavor to your custom cake.

  • Custard

  • Chocolate Fudge

  • Chocolate Mousse

  • Raspberry

  • Strawberry

  • Oreo

  • Lemon 

Custom Cake Pricing Guide

My cakes are not just delicious; they’re a feast for the eyes. You have the freedom to enhance them with custom colors, beautiful flowers, vibrant sprinkles, or themed toppers.

All prices listed below are base prices for two-layer cakes (approx. 4″ tall) with basic decorations (simple flowers, colors, sprinkles). Any extra designs, decorations, premium fillings, or anything beyond basic frosting may have additional charges.

All orders require a 50% non-refundable deposit, with the remainder due upon pickup.

Round and Square Cakes

Standard cakes are two layers.

  • 6” Round: $55

  • 9” Round: $75

  • 9” Square: $75

  • 12” Round: $115

Sheet Cakes

Standard sheet cakes are a single layer.

  • Quarter Sheet: $60

  • Half Sheet: $90

Specialty Cupcakes

  • One Dozen: $25

Start Your Custom Cake Order Today!

Ready to design the perfect cake for your event in Firestone, Longmont, or anywhere in Northern Colorado? Contact me today to get a custom quote and start your order.