Handcrafted Custom Cakes & Cupcakes serving Firestone, Longmont, Frederick, Dacono, and surrounding Northern Colorado communities.

Custom Cake Flavors & Base Pricing | Longmont & Firestone, CO

Custom Cakes in Northern Colorado | Cactus Cake with Butterfly - custom cake pricing in Longmont

Custom Cake Flavors & Base Pricing | Longmont & Firestone, CO

Because every cake from Sugar High Cakes is uniquely designed and handcrafted, final pricing depends on size, design complexity, fondant detail, and specialty ingredients.

To help you plan your event budget, below are our starting base prices and flavor options for custom cakes and cupcakes in Firestone and Longmont, CO.

Base Starting Prices

Note: Base prices include standard buttercream frosting and simple decorative piping. Custom fondant work, cake toppers, drip finishes, sculpted elements, or complex themes will add to the final estimate.

Custom Round Layer Cakes

  • 6-Inch Round (Serves ~10): Starts at $55
  • 9-Inch Round (Serves ~20): Starts at $75
  • 12-Inch Round (Serves ~30): Starts at $115
  • Multi-Tiered Cakes: Inquire for custom quote

Custom Sheet Cakes

  • 1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves ~18): Starts at $60
  • 1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves ~36): Starts at $90

Custom Cupcakes

  • Standard Cupcakes: Starting at $25 per dozen (1 dozen minimum per flavor)

My Signature Cake Flavors & Fillings

Classic Cake Flavors

  • Classic Vanilla Bean: Light, fluffy, and infused with pure vanilla extract.
  • Chocolate Midnight: Deep, decadent chocolate cake for true cocoa lovers.
  • Confetti: Vibrant rainbow sprinkles baked inside vanilla cake.
  • Red Velvet: Classic southern red velvet with a hint of cocoa.
  • Lemon: Bright, zesty refreshing citrus cake.
  • Marble: Swirled vanilla and rich chocolate cake.
  • Cookies & Cream: Vanilla cake packed with crushed chocolate cookies.
  • White Chocolate: A sweet and creamy white chocolate cake.
  • Carrot: Made with fresh carrots, pineapple and a blend of warm spices.

Gourmet Buttercreams & Frostings

  • Classic Vanilla Buttercream
  • Rich Chocolate Buttercream
  • Peanut Butter Frosting

Fillings

  • Custard
  • Chocolate Fudge
  • Chocolate Mousse
  • Oreo
  • Raspberry
  • Strawberry
  • Lemon

What Factors Influence Custom Cake Cost?

When we create a custom quote for your cake in Northern Colorado, we evaluate:

  1. Number of Servings: Determines tier sizing and structural support needed.
  2. Design Complexity: Hand-sculpted fondant figures, intricate piping, metallic accents, or sugar flowers require extra labor and detail.
  3. Specialty Elements: Edible photo prints, custom acrylic toppers, fresh flowers, or custom toy toppers.

Ready for an Exact Price Estimate?

Provide us with your event date, estimated guest count, and design inspiration to receive an accurate, no-obligation quote!

Request a Custom Price Quote